Through the Transmission Workgroup, the NWCC was a leading facilitator and resource to stakeholders and worked to ensure that wind power receives fair – though not preferential – treatment with respect to transmission services.
Between 1999 and 2010, the NWCC contributed significantly to enabling wind power’s expansion by engaging industry, federal and state agencies, legislators, environmental organizations, and regulators in dialogues to examine issues that impact the integration of wind power onto the transmission grid and generate solutions that address the transmission challenges facing wind power development.
By providing a national model of collaboration and a forum for other stakeholders to participate in transmission planning processes, the NWCC Transmission Workgroup made a contribution to transforming the transmission planning landscape from an isolated, expert-driven decision-making process to an increasingly open and collaborative process accommodating a larger group of stakeholders and their interests. This model was ratified by Congress and applied to the entire country in the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA), which required the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) to engage the three national grids in planning that included stakeholder participation.
Over the course of 12 years, NWCC’s studies, education, outreach, and meetings resulted in many achievements by:
- stimulating dialogue;
- providing education that enabled hundreds of people to take part knowledgeably in transmission discussions;
- increasing the wind community’s awareness of the complexities of reliable power system operation and the technical issues arising from wind integration;
- informing policy and regulatory decisions across the country; and
- prompting increased consideration of wind power’s value.
Notably, NWCC has contributed to the following initiatives, studies, and goals:
- Western Governors’ Association’s (WGA) Clean and Diversified Energy Analysis project and Western Renewable Energy Zones (WREZ) Initiative
- Western Electricity Coordinating Council’s Regional Transmission Expansion Planning project
- Midwestern Independent System Operator’s (MISO) 20% wind study plans
- CAPX2020 initiative in Minnesota
- Joint Coordinated System Plan study
- Midwestern Governors Association (MGA) Renewables and Transmission Goals
To read a summary of the outcomes, approach, history, and successes of the NWCC Transmission Workgroup since its inception, please click here.
Transmission Policy Institute
June 17-18, 2010, Denver, Colorado
Increasing Renewable Energy in the Western Grid: A Dialogue Among Stakeholders
May 10-11, 2010, Golden, Colorado
Electrical Transmission Forum: Transition to a Reduced Carbon Energy Economy
February 22, 2010, Washington, DC
Renewables Initiatives Forum
March 10, 2009, Washington, DC
Over 50 leaders participated in the NWCC Renewables Initiatives Forum: Dialogue on Implementation Issues for Renewables and Transmission. The forum provided the opportunity for stakeholders and decision makers to gain further insight into the collaboration and coordination that is necessary to meet the goals of the aggressive national energy agenda.
High Plains Transmission Summit
November 3, 2009, Lawrence, Kansas
Leaders gathered in Lawrence, Kansas on November 3, 2009, to identify cross-border impediments to transmission line planning and construction in the high plains region.
- Final Agenda
- Lauren Azar, WI Commission
- Linda Blair, ITC
- Jay Caspary, SPP
- John DiDonato, Nextera Energy
- John Flynn, AEP
- Steve Gaw, Wind Coalition
- Kelly Harrison, Westar Energy
- Scott Helyer, Tenaska
- Carl Holmes, KETA
- John Lawhorn, MISO
- Phil Moeller, FERC
- Mike Moffett, KCC Commission
- Brad Roberts, S & C Electric Company; Jeff Palermo, KEMA
- John Schnagl, DOE
- Jeremy Turner, RETA
- David Whiteley, Eastern Interconnection Planning Collaborative
Wind and Transmission 101 Workshop
July 30, 2008 – Dearborn, Michigan
At this meeting, participants were introduced to the potential for wind power to provide energy in the Midwest and provided a foundation on wind energy and transmission issues.
Midwestern Wind Energy: Moving it to Markets
July 31-August 1, 2008 – Dearborn, Michigan
Wind Energy and Transmission: The South Dakota Landscape
November 29-30, 2007 – Sioux Falls, South Dakota
Western Transmission and Wildlife Needs at a Crosswords: A Topical Workshop
September 26, 2007 – Fort Collins, Colorado
WGA/NWCC Summit: Increasing Renewable Energy in the Western Grid
September 27-28, 2007 – Fort Collins, Colorado
Southwest Power Pool Workshop III
August 22, 2007 – Dallas, Texas
Midwest Wind & Transmission Workshop VI
December 4-5, 2006 – Bloomington, Minnesota
Leadership Forum: Implementing Transmission Recommendations in the West
July 18-19, 2006 – Denver, Colorado
Southwest Power Pool Workshop II
September 19, 2005 – Topeka, Kansas
Midwest Transmission Meeting
June 22, 2005 – St. Paul, Minnesota
Western Transmission Workshop III
February 1-2, 2005 – Sacramento, California
Southwest Power Pool Workshop I
October 25-26, 2004 – Little Rock, Arkansas
Transmission Planning and Wind in the Western U.S.
February 26-27, 2005 – San Diego, California
Western Transmission Planning Principles
June 3-4, 2003 – Portland, Oregon
Western Transmission Workshop
January 22, 2003 – Salt Lake City Utah
Midwest Transmission Meeting
December 5, 2002 – St. Paul, Minnesota
Upper Midwest Transmission Workshop II
March 12-13, 2005 – St. Paul, Minnesota
Upper Midwest Transmission Workshop I
May 1-2, 2001 – Minneapolis, Minessota
Transmission Subcommittee Meeting
March 1-2, 2000
Transmission Subcommittee Meeting
November 29, 1999
NWCC Transmission Publications
Transmission Workgroup: History and Accomplishments
Between 1999 and 2010, the National Wind Coordinating Collaborative (NWCC) contributed significantly to enabling wind power’s expansion by engaging industry, federal and state agencies, legislators, environmental organizations, and regulators in dialogues to examine issues that impact the integration of wind power onto the transmission grid and generate solutions that address the transmission challenges facing wind power development.
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid: Perspectives for Policymakers
This paper explores how utilities, regulators and policymakers are addressing wind power reliability and integration, enabling more states to meet renewable energy production targets and environmental goals. Produced by the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) in cooperation with the NWCC.
Transmission Planning Principles
This consensus document articulates standards and criteria to guide planning entities in developing transmission expansion and upgrade proposals.
NWCC Transmission Updates
2010: February, April, June, August, November, December
2009: February, May, June, August, October, December
2008: April, June, July, August, September, December
2007: March, June, October, December
2006: February, April, June, August, October
2005: March, April, June, August, October, December
2004: January, March, July
2003: February, April, June, September, November
2002: October, December
NWCC Transmission Issue Briefs
Transmission Planning and Wind Energy
Reexamines transmission planning and how best to conduct it in a changing market environment. Considers planning for the addition of new transmission capacity, making the best use of existing transmission capacity and incorporating non-transmission alternatives.
Wind Energy Interconnection
Examines commonly cited interconnection issues, as well as specific issues with interconnecting wind generators, in regards to FERC’s ruling on interconnecting large and small wind generators.
FERC Order 890: What Does It Mean for the West?
Scheduling requirements and real-time market design rules can determine whether wind generators can effectively participate in electricity markets. Presents options for resolving the issues faced by wind generators in balancing markets.
Wind Energy, Congestion Management, and Transmission Rights
Brief looks at emerging regional congestion management strategies, their implications for wind, and options for addressing these barriers to wind generation.
Other NWCC Transmission Publications
Implementing Wind Energy & Transmission in the West
Renewable Energy Zone Planning Webinar Series
Electric transmission improvement and expansion currently ranks high on the national energy agenda, highlighting an opportunity to review current state and regional transmission planning processes. Building new transmission requires planning, paying for, permitting, and siting lines. In addition to traditional transmission planning, that focuses on reli¬ability and economics, new landscape-level, collaborative planning approaches have emerged to bring wildlife and other land use interests to the table early in the transmission planning process. This series of webcasts addressed the state of the art landscape planning activities performed at state and regional levels.
Western Renewable Energy Zone initiative and Renewable Energy Transmission Access Advisory Committee
September 28, 2009
The third webinar featured the recently completed Phase 1 of the Western Governor’s Association (WGA) Western Renewable Energy Zone (WREZ) planning process-a significant multistage and stakeholder initiative. Leaders from the WGA, WREZ’s Technical Committee and work groups discussed the process and lessons learned. The recently released Phase II report of Nevada’s Renewable Energy Transmission Access Advisory Committee (RETAAC) was also featured.
California Renewable Energy Transmission Initiative\
August 24, 2009
RETI is is a statewide initiative to help identify the transmission projects needed to accommodate these renewable energy goals, support future energy policy, and facilitate transmission corridor designation and transmission and generation siting and permitting. Presenters provided detailed overviews of RETI, wildlife and habitat data incorporated into the zone identification process, and wind industry perspectives on the process.
State Renewable Energy Zone Planning: Arizona & Colorado
July 27, 2009
In the first webinar, participants sought to understand the purpose and goals of planning processes in Arizona and Colorado, as well as the challenges associated with data collection and the technical tools used to identify and classify zones.
NWCC/WGA Transmission Products Webinar
February 2, 2007
This webcast explored conditional firm and redispatch, two transmission products that, at the time, were under consideration by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in its proposed Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) reform NOPR.
Natalie McIntire, Renewable Northwest Project
Don Furman, PPM Energy
Conditional firm transmission service is a way for more generators to use existing transmission lines under long-term contracts. Redispatch is a method of resolving transmission congestion by changing generator output levels to reduce congestion, which may enable additional firm transmission sales. Featured speakers addressed how these transmission products work, when and where they might apply, benefits, and challenges.
The WGA Clean and Diversified Energy Advisory Committee (CDEAC) recommendations call for “implementing a conditional-firm, re-dispatch, and related tariff reform transmission products where feasible and consistent with the policy of an independent system operator or regional transmission organization.” This webinar is part of WGA and NWCC’s work to implement the CDEAC recommendations.
ACE Diversity Interchange (ADI): A method of regional regulation among participating control areas that can achieve a mutual reduction in regulation requirements and generator output adjustments (ramping).
Area Control Error (ACE): A measure of the difference between an electrical control area’s (or balancing authority’s) actual and scheduled generation, taking frequency bias into account.
Allowance for Funds Used During Construction (AFUDC): Approval by FERC and state regulatory commissions for inclusion in rates of the cost of borrowing funds until a project is placed into operation.
Available Transmission Capacity (ATC): A measure of the electric transfer capability remaining in the transmission network for sale over and above already committed uses.
Balancing Authority: The entity responsible for operating a control area (see below). It matches generation with loads and maintains frequency within limits.
Bonneville Power Administration (BPA): The federal power marketing authority in the Northwest (OR, WA, ID, MT) that markets wholesale power from federal dams on the Columbia and Snake Rivers and owns and operates a high-voltage transmission system.
California Independent System Operator (CAISO): The entity in California that controls and administers nondiscriminatory access to electric transmission across investor-owned utility systems independent of their ownership.
Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (CPCN): The license granted to a public utility by a state regulatory agency to build and own transmission and other electricity or gas infrastructure.
Clean and Diversified Energy Advisory Committee (CDEAC): The stakeholder committee established by the Western Governors Association in 2005 to draft recommendations to implement a resolution to develop 30 GW of clean energy by 2015 and 20% energy efficiency by 2020.
Colorado Coordinated Planning Group (CCPG): A group of utilities, transmission owners, and stakeholders that study transmission expansion needs in Colorado.
Conditional Firm Service: A tariff proposal under consideration both at Bonneville Power Administration and in the FERC 888 OATT Reform NOPR. Conditional Firm service would be long-term, and firm for a pre-defined number of months during the year, combined with a specified number of hours over a set number of “conditional” months when firm transmission service may not be provided. This can allow the transmission provider to offer more service and potentially serve new resources that would otherwise not be able to get on line.
Control Area: Electric power system in which operators match loads to resources within the system, maintain scheduled interchange between control areas, maintain frequency within reasonable limits, and provide sufficient generation capacity to maintain operating reserves. Same as Balancing Authority.
Curtailment: A reduction in the scheduled capacity or energy delivery due to a transmission constraint or power shortage.
Demand Side Management (DSM): A collection of methods for reducing electricity or gas demand including conservation, energy efficiency, tariffed or contracted interruptions, bidding during peak power events, appliance standards, and appliance controls.
Dynamic Line Rating: The transmission operator practice of increasing the line rating and thermal limits of a given transmission line in real time when the cooling effects of wind or weather occur.
Dynamic Scheduling: An accounting for power plant output in a neighboring control area, so the balancing authority that is host to a wind facility has no responsibility for scheduling.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC): A federal agency created in 1977 to regulate, among other things, interstate wholesale markets and transportation of gas and electricity at “just and reasonable rates.” FERC is the successor of the Federal Power Commission (FPC), established in 1920.
Notice of Inquiry (NOI): A notice of inquiry by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission or a state PUC with a comment period to solicit comments and recommendations on a specific issue.
Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NOPR): A notice of a proposed rulemaking issued by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, asking for comments and declaring the intent to formally adopt the rule.
FERC Order 888: The current rules for regulating and setting prices for the US wholesale electricity market including standards for the terms and conditions for open access tariffs (OATT).
Firm Transmission: Transmission service that may not be interrupted for any reason except during an emergency when continued delivery of power is not possible.
Flow-based Methodology: A method for determining available transmission capacity (ATC) based on actual physical electricity flows rather than financial contracts.
Imbalance Penalties: FERC-tariffed penalties imposed on generators by transmission owners based on deviations from schedules. These penalties are intended to prevent generators from gaming wholesale markets. Imbalance penalties for variable out put generators like wind are deemed unfair because wind output is not controllable in the same way fossil fuel generators are.
Independent System Operator (ISO): Entity that controls and administers nondiscriminatory access to electric transmission in a region or across several systems, independent from the owners of the facilities.
Integrated Resource Planning (IRP): An approach to planning which compares the full life-cycle costs, including social and environmental costs, of a broad spectrum of alternatives.
Investor Owned Utility (IOU): A utility regulated by state and federal commissions and statutes that is privately-owned by its shareholders.
Load Serving Entity (LSE): Any entity providing service to load.
Network Transmission (NT): A transmission contract or service as described in a transmission provider’s Open Access Transmission Tariff filed with the FERC.
Non-Firm Transmission Service: Transmission service that may be interrupted in favor of firm transmission schedules or for other reasons.
Northwest Transmission Assessment Committee (NTAC): A group of utilities, transmission owners, and stakeholders that studies transmission needs in the Pacific Northwest and makes recommendations to members of the Northwest Power Pool.
Open Access Same-time Information System (OASIS): A web-based information system linking individual transmission owner OASIS websites that list available capacity on specific transmission lines.
Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT): A FERC regulated tariff under Order 888 and 889 that is intended to ensure that transmission services are provided on a basis that is just, reasonable and not unduly discriminatory or preferential.
Operating Transfer Capacity (OTC): Represents the real time operating capability that recognizes the actual line operating conditions at a given hour.
Participating Transmission Owner (PTO): A transmission owner who agrees to place its facilities under the operational control of an RTO/ISO.
Performance-based Regulation (PBR): A departure from rate base, rate of return regulation that bases a utility’s revenues and/or profits on measurable performance criteria, usually aimed at changing the company’s incentives to align them more with the interests of customers, society, and/or the environment.
Postage Stamp Pricing: Flat rates charged for transmission service without regard to distance.
Power Marketing Authority (PMA): One of several federal entities that market power from federally owned and operated generators and sometimes own or operate federal transmission infrastructure in the United States. WAPA and BPA are examples in the West.
Priority Non-Firm: Similar to non-firm, except that priority non-firm can be procured on a long term basis, and has a higher curtailment priority than traditional non-firm (is curtailed after traditional non-firm).
Prudence Review: A regulatory proceeding that determines if an IOU investment is just and reasonable and allowable for full cost-recovery in rates given the information available to the utility at the time it was made.
Public Utility Commission (PUC): These state regulatory authorities are appointed by the governor or elected by the people to set rates for electricity, gas, telephone and other monopoly services imbued with the public interest. PUC’s often provide consumer information and mediation services, and administer programs defined in state statutes.
Rate Pancaking: Fees that are tacked on as electricity flows through a number of transmission systems.
Redispatch: The modification of generating schedules and/or demand side management, usually to reduce congestion in transmission systems. This product would allow a transmission owner to offer more long-term service when their system in constrained on one or more paths by arranging for dispatch of generation resources to relieve those constraints when the system is at peak usage. When the flow of electricity on transmission lines is at or over capacity, increasing generation on one side of the constraint, and decreasing it on the other side of the constraint can relieve the congestion. A transmission provider must consider how many hours of the year this service might be needed and arrange for generator(s) on both sides of the constraint to provide adjustment. This arrangement then allows the transmission provider to treat the customer purchasing transmission with redispatch like a firm customer. Commercial Redispatch must be considered under the 888 OATT Section 13.5 if there is no long-term firm capacity available to serve a customer’s request. However utilities have not yet offered it.
Regional Transmission Organization (RTO): An independent regional transmission operator and service provider that meets certain criteria, including those related to independence and market size, established by FERC Order 2000.
Reliability: Term used to describe a utility’s ability to deliver an uninterrupted stream of energy to its customers and how well the utility’s system can handle an unexpected shock that may affect generation, transmission or distribution service.
Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS): A standard set by a state or the federal government that requires affected LSEs to acquire a minimum percentage electricity to be generated or purchased from renewable resources.
Right-of-Way (ROW): Strip of land used for utility lines. Most utilities negotiate easements with property owners or use the power of eminent domain to gain access. In some cases, the land is purchased outright.
Rocky Mountain Area Transmission Study (RMATS): A study initiated in 2003 by the governors of Wyoming and Utah to examine transmission needs in the CO-ID-MT-UT-WY region. It issued a report in 2004 that recommended a number of transmission upgrades, expansions, and operational reforms based on production cost modeling that demonstrated significant economic benefits to the region.
Southwest Area Transmission group (SWAT): A sub-regional planning group that includes utilities, transmission owners and stakeholders in Arizona and New Mexico.
Southwest Transmission Expansion Plan (STEP): A sub regional planning group that includes utilities, transmission owners, and stakeholders in California, Nevada, and Arizona.
Tariff: A document, approved by the responsible regulatory agency, listing the binding terms and conditions, including prices, under which utility services will be provided.
Transmission: The process of transporting wholesale electrical energy at high voltages from a supply source to utilities.
Transmission Dependent Utility (TDU): A utility that owns and operates little or no transmission and is therefore dependent on another entity for transmission services.
Transmission Owner (TO): The owner of transmission facilities. A Transmission Owner may or may not be responsible for providing transmission service.
Transmission Provider (TP): The entity responsible for providing transmission service, subject to reliability, regulatory and commercial requirements. A Transmission Provider may or may not own the facilities it is responsible for.
Unused Transmission Capacity (UTC): A recently-coined term used in the RMATS study to identify available capacity on a given transmission line or path (a collection of lines between two areas) based on actual physical flows rather then financial contracts or ownership.
Used and Useful Test: A regulatory test to determine if the plant or transmission infrastructure investments made by a utility are actually in service and therefore subject to full cost-recovery, i.e. used, and if it was a good investment compared with alternatives, i.e. useful.
Utility Wind Integration Group (UWIG): An organization whose membership includes utilities that own, operate or purchase wind power and which have an interest in wind integration and supply issues. The organization participates in proceedings and meetings at the national level and provides technical assistance and publications to its members. http://variablegen.org/newsroom/.
Variable Output Resource: An energy resource like wind or solar that generates electricity depending on weather or solar insolation or other uncontrollable forces.
Vertically Integrated Utility: A traditional electric utility that has direct control over its transmission, distribution, and generation facilities and can offer a full range of power services.
Western Area Power Administration (WAPA): A federal power marketing authority that owns or operates generation and transmission facilities primarily in the interior western US.
Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC): The voluntary electric industry reliability organization responsible for grid reliability in the western interconnection including Canadian provinces and Mexican states connected to the US grid.
Western Governors Association (WGA): The association of governors in the western US from Hawaii and Alaska to the Dakotas and Texas.
Western Interconnection: The synchronous grid that is connected across states and provinces in the west not including ERCOT in Texas or Alaska and Hawaii. It also includes British Columbia, Alberta, and Saskatchewan in Canada and Baja del Norte in Mexico.
wesTTrans: A voluntary, cooperative open access (OASIS) website providing a common platform for the posting of available transmission capacity, independent of ownership. WesTTrans.net complements but does not replace the individual OASIS sites maintained by individual Transmission Owners. It serves a significant portion of the Western Interconnection.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
National Council on Electric Policy (June 2004) Electricity Transmission: A Primer.
North American Energy Standards Board
Western Interstate Energy Board
BLM: Bureau of Land Management
DOE: Department of Energy
EIA: Energy Information Administration
EPA: Environmental Protection Agency
FAA: Federal Aviation Administration
FERC: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
FTC: Federal Trade Commission
NREL: National Renewable Energy Laboratory
SEC: Securities and Exchange Commission
APPA: American Public Power Association
AWEA: American Wind Energy Association
BPA: Bonneville Power Administration
NARUC: National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissions
NGA: National Governors Association
NERC: National Electric Reliability Council
NRECA: National Rural Electric Cooperative Association
NWCC: National Wind Coordinating Collaborative
SSG-WI: Steering Group –Western Interconnection
UWIG: Utility Wind Interest Group
WAPA: Western Area Power Authority
WECC: Western Electricity Coordinating Council
WGA: Western Governors Association
EA: Environmental Assessment
EIA: Environmental Impact Statement
EPACT: Energy Policy Act of 1992
ISO: Independent System Operator
MSE: Multi-State Entity
RTO: Regional Transmission Organizations
PTC: Production Tax Credit
PUHCA: Public Utility Holding Company Act of 1935
PURPA: Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978
RES: Renewable Energy Standard
RPS: Renewable Portfolio Standard
SMD: Standard Market Design
AC: Alternate Current
AGC: Automatic Generation Control
ACE: Area Control Error
ATC: Available Transfer Capacity
CAO: Control Area Operators
CBM: Capacity Benefit Margin
CCN: Certificate of Convenience and Necessity
CREPC: Committee for Regional Electric Power Cooperation
DC: Direct Current
EMF: Electromagnetic Field
ERCOT: Electric Reliability Council of Texas
FTR: Financial Transmission Rights
kV: Kilovolts IOU: Investor Owned Utility
IPP: Independent Power Producers
IRP: Integrated Resource Planning
ISA: Independent System Administrator
LDC: Local Distribution Companies
LFC: Load Frequency Control
LFRR: Load Following Reserve Requirements
LSE: Load Serving Entity
MAPP: Mid-Continent Area Power Pool
MISO: Midwest Independent System Operator
MOU: Municipally Owned Utilities MW: Megawatts
NEES: New England Electric System
NEPOOL: New England Regional Power Pool
OASIS: Open Access Same-Time Information System
PJM: Pennsylvania- New Jersey- Maryland Interconnection
PPD: Public Power District
PUD: Public Utility District
PUC: Public Utility Commission
PXs: Power Exchanges
RATC: Recallable Available Transmission Capability
REC: Regional Electric Cooperative
SPP: Southwest Power Pool
TRM: Transmission Reliability Margin
TTC: Total Transmission Capability