National Wind Coordinating Committee
National Wind Coordinating Committee
National Wind Coordinating Committee
National Wind Coordinating Collaborative

Upper Midwest Transmission Workshop

Agenda

May 1-2, 2001
Embassy Suites Hotel
Minneapolis, MN 55415

Tuesday, March 12, 2002

8:00 Continental Breakfast
8:30 Session I: Introductions
  • Participant introductions
  • Review purpose of workshop
  • Review agenda
9:00-9:45 Session II: Overview of Current Situation for Transmission Planning in the Midwest
TBD, including discussion

Objective: Set the stage for the workshop, and present stakeholder perceptions of the current situation in the region with respect to transmission planning.

  • What transmission planning infrastructure is already in place, and what are its key strengths and shortcomings?
  • What planning is underway and where does it lead?
9:45-2:00 Session III: Overview of Projections for 2012 — What Are Reasonable Scenarios?

Objective: Present and discuss a range of plausible scenarios that improve understanding of the scope of transmission requirements for the next decade; develop an improved understanding of the complexity of this problem and the difficulty of obtaining needed planning information.

For each scenario:

  • What planning assumptions and inputs are required?
  • What transmission modeling studies would determine transmission priorities and relative transmission and overall costs of the scenarios?
9:45-10:00 Session Introduction
10:00-10:30 Break
10:30-11:15 Scenario Presentation and Discussion:
Business as Usual
Baseline load forecast
Natural Gas Generation near loads
Current Wholesale/retail split
MAPP/MISO TPSC Representative
11:15-12:00 Scenario Presentation and Discussion: Wind Power Development in the Upper Midwest Current status of wind development, drivers (economics, policy, demand), projections (amounts, location, markets, timetable), transmission issues (current studies, corridors needed to get wind to market).
Wind on the Wires Representative
12:00-1:00 Lunch
1:00-2:00 Scenario Presentation and Discussion: Variation of the above, or a whole new scenario based on an established RTO operating effectively over a large region. (Transition to open, competitive markets for transmission services -- firm/flexible rates, imbalance penalty exemptions, dead-band reduces over time, etc. Wholesale market serves a larger percentage of load. Wind, coal splits generation with gas. Hydro, gas hybrids operate with wind. Affected landowners become project partners.)
TBD
2:00-2:40 Session IV: Process for Determining Transmission Improvements Needed to Accommodate the 2012 Situation
MAPP/MISO TPSC

Objective: Improve understanding of the existing technical process for identifying, addressing and evaluating transmission needs; identify information, planning inputs and assumptions and level of detail beyond that discussed in Session III needed to study, design and describe an appropriately robust transmission system for 2012.

Layman’s Overview of the Technical Process

2:40-3:00 Looking ahead to 2012, How Could We Begin to Refine the Process for the 2012 Situation?
Group Discussion, Initiated by MAPP/MISO TPSC
  • what has been done? and
  • what else needs to be done?
3:00-3:15 Break
3:15-4:00 Session IV, continued
4:00-5:00 Session V: Consideration of Proposed Improvements
Moderated Group Discussion

Objective: Identify the full range of entities and individuals affected by proposed transmission improvements; understand their needs and concerns, and identify the criteria they will use in evaluating possible transmission improvements.

  • Who needs to consider the improvements?
  • Are they involved now?
  • How can they be brought into a collaborative process?
  • What issues will these parties raise? (e.g., reliability, economics, line routing and selection of rights of way, compensation for easements, environmental considerations and inclusiveness of public process)
5:00 Adjourn for the Day

 
Wednesday, March 13, 2002

8:00 Continental Breakfast
8:30-8:45 Review Day I and Agree on Agenda for Day 2
8:45-9:45 Session VI: Selecting Proposed Transmission Improvements through Scenarios and Stakeholder Deliberation.
Group discussion with introduction

Objective: Develop criteria for identifying transmission proposals that mesh with the scenarios discussed on Day 1. With the benefit of the enhanced stakeholder process discussed on Day 1, use these criteria to select a set of transmission proposals for consideration, outreach and education.

Proposed selection criteria and refinement through discussion

9:45-10:00 Description of leading proposed line additions, including supporting logic and key issues
MAPP/MISO TPSC
10:00-11:30 Preliminary selection of a straw-man set of transmission upgrades and additions for detailed consideration
Group discussion
11:30 Session VII: Conclusions and Wrap-up

Objective: Evaluate progress, discuss ways in which the process can be carried forward by regional stakeholders, and identify future NWCC work that could be helpful in support of regional stakeholders.

Assess Progress and Discuss Next Steps • Process continuation and refinement • Who else needs to be involved? • Progress relative to workshop objectives • What else can NWCC do to be helpful?

12:00 Adjourn Workshop, followed by lunch

 
About NWCC | Membership | Workgroups | Meetings/Events | Publications | Resources

© 1998-2007 NATIONAL WIND COORDINATING COLLABORATIVE
Formerly known as the National Wind Coordinating Committee
c/o RESOLVE, 1255 23rd Street NW, Suite 875, Washington, DC 20037
(888) 764-WIND (202) 965-6398 fax: (202) 338-1264
Send Comments, Questions, or Suggestions to: nwcc@resolv.org